?

Log in

No account? Create an account
~生まれた町で夢見てきた...~
"In the city of my birth, I had a dream..."
Hot Gimmick S by Nishizaki Megumi 
27th-Apr-2008 09:15 pm
Golden
Nishizaki, Megumi. Hot Gimmick S. Trans. Sawaka Kawashima and John Werry. San Francisco: VIZ Media, 2007.
          Summary: With illustrations by Aihara Miki. This light novel traces the story of the Hot Gimmick manga and then concludes with a very different ending. Shinogu's tragic past as the son of Hatsumi's mother Shihoko's alcoholic best friend is revealed, and when he is injured while trying to rescue a tourist trapped on a mountain, Hatsumi's at last starts to realize her feelings for him.
          Comments: Err...why am I reading this book? Or, better yet, why am I reading this book in English?! The language and vocabulary are so simplistic that it's clear that this barely-there excuse for a novel would have been a cakewalk for me even in the original Japanese. (If all the Palette Bunko titles are like this, maybe I should try picking up some for practice.) But then, I didn't know that, and I was curious about VIZ Media's first (and last?) foray into the shoujo light novel field. Even after reading it, though, I'm not sure why they chose to license it. Was the original manga that popular? It surely isn't going to contribute anything to America's appreciation of Japanese literature.
          For those who have been keeping track here, the "S" in the title stands for Shinogu...and apparently a lot of people in Japan as well were dissatisfied with the manga's Ryoki-centric denouement. Okay, so it's still sorta scandalous because Hatsumi and Shinogu are kinda brother and sister, but at least Shinogu is a "nice guy." Nice guys tend to lose out in romance novels and shoujo manga alike--and let's face it: In real life the girl loses out if she doesn't choose a nice guy. The backstory involving Yuko and her abusive husband should make that abundantly clear. I'm glad to see this story resolved in a more healthful fashion. It's just a shame Aihara didn't get it right the first time.
          Notes: trade paperback, 1st American edition; first published in Japan by Shougakukan in 2005
          Rating: 5/10 - Fans of the manga series and of Shinogu in particular should be pleased. Newcomers to the story, on the other hand, are liable to refuse to believe that this even counts as literature.
Comments 
28th-Apr-2008 01:40 am (UTC)
apparently a lot of people in Japan as well were dissatisfied with the manga's Ryoki-centric denouement
oh... That's interesting! I had no idea Ryoki was not popular. He is such a typical shoujo manga romantic hero... or perhaps I should stop reading so much cruel shoujo smut?
28th-Apr-2008 01:46 am (UTC)
The author of the novel said (translated), "Argh" at the thought of Ryoki winning the day in the manga. I think it's safe to assume that, for this novel to exist in the first place, she was not the only one.
This page was loaded Feb 19th 2018, 7:45 am GMT.